(the video is not important, only the song)
What strikes me about this song is the melancholy happiness it preaches. The tone; the sound of the song is so mysterious, so sorrowful, as are the various verses, yet the bridge and chorus are so hopeful. They preach a rising of the children's voices, while they themselves seem to be just that: Nick Cave leads the choir in this rhapsodizing of despair to hope.
The transition from the repeated "Children, rejoice" and "Children, lift up your voice" to "Hey little train we're jumping on the train that goes to the kingdom. We're happy ma, we're having fun, and the train ain't even left the station" is so powerful to me. It represent so much of what I feel in life, and what I hope for. The contentedness expressed in the mere words of the lyrics is something that I so want to feel. I want to be happy with and excited about whichever train I decide to take. But is anyone so lucky as to feel this way? Thus, the dark tone of the song leads me to a deeper interpretation of this part. That is, the speaker is convincing the mother archetype that he is happy, genuinely content with wherever he may be in life. He is, in fact, convincing himself, as it is easy to get wrapped up in the moving transition from the beginning and middle of the song to the end. The end is more uplifting, certainly, but amidst the claims of "We're happy ma, we're having fun" still lies the obscure taste of melancholy on the singer/speaker's lips. I find it sad that happiness is something that one wants so badly and so desperately to achieve that he must convince himself that he has, in fact, obtained that happiness, contentedness.
Lizzie! I absolutely love this song as well! But, I must say, reading your wonderful interpretation while listening to it made for an enlightening as well as relaxing experience! ☺
ReplyDeleteI was especially struck by your words, “happiness is something that one wants so badly and so desperately to achieve that he must convince himself that he has, in fact, obtained that happiness, contentedness.” Upon reflection, I realized this is completely true. Often, before I go to bed, I will verbally reassure myself that I had a good day and that there is so much to look forward to tomorrow. And, as spontaneous as happiness is supposed to be, it usually ends up being planned, attached to certain objects or outcomes. For example, almost everyday, I hear students whisper that they “will be happy” as long as they pass that one test or quiz. Here, there is virtually no distinction between the passing grade and the state of happiness; they are the same.
So what is true happiness really? Sometimes it comes with a sense of well-being in one’s own life, with the sense that everything is going as planned. Often, however, people extract happiness from the well-being of others. In “O Children”, he wasn’t only trying to convince himself of his happiness, but also his ma. His ma probably would feel happiness from the knowledge that her son is happy, and vice versa. In fact, it’s a never-ending cycle.
I then found myself wondering, “What really makes us more happy: actual people, objects or ideas which externally instigate that release of serotonin in our brain, or the mere thought of being happy?” I had never really considered this second possible source until reading your post, and I’ve come to realize that, more often than not, that is what I strive for. Whether this is a good or bad thing, I don’t pretend to know, but this has definitely got me thinking!
Thanks for the enlightenment, Lizzie! Ooh, and the great music.
Hello Lizzie! I never saw this song as anything more than pleasing to the ears. I never questioned the reason why it was chosen for HPDHP2… until now!
ReplyDeleteThe juxtaposition of despair and happiness that you wrote about is precisely the atmosphere during that scene in HPDHP2. In the middle of the frigid countryside, abandoned by Ron, Harry and Hermione have no plan of action, not a smidgen of hope. In a moment of pure spontaneity, they dance together. They have a moment of such unburdened joy that you can’t even see the despair lurking behind a corner. While to some, the scene was hokey and unnecessary, I saw it as a beautiful moment to hold on to. Though if I were to follow your train of thought, I’d question the expression on Hermione’s face as she presses it into Harry’s shoulder. Is she content? Or are thoughts of danger and loneliness creeping there way in?
On a non-Harry Potter related note, I wonder if sometimes the anticipation of happiness is even greater than the experience itself? Nick Cave sings, “We're happy ma, we're having fun, and the train ain't even left the station” Is that a happiness for things to come? Or happiness right now, knowing that no matter where the train takes you it will be alright. I think there is so much more depth and quality to the latter feeling. With that, there’s no need to convince anyone that you’re happy because you know that no matter the trials and tribulations, it will be possible to find happiness again. Happiness is a very complex idea to think about, isn’t it? Or maybe it’s simple and we’re doing the ‘human thing’ of blowing it completely out of proportion.
I find that when I’m truly happy, there’s no need to brood over it. But when I feel forlorn or simply bored with life, happiness is completely theoretical. In that state, happiness is an idea to be stretched and squeezed and molded into all different shapes. But in it’s purest form, I worry that questioning happiness will only taint it. Thank you for sparking this, Lizzie!