I first commented on Kevin's blog entry, "Metacognition: The Mashup." Within Kevin's discussion of the "mashing-up" process, he explains how his Jane Eyre theme, individualism, is apparent even in the seemingly universal, collective internet. My comment as follows:
Kevin, what you say about individualism within the collective network of the internet was a sort of wake-up call for me. All-too-frequently, I find myself taking the abundance of material on the internet for granted. I never take the time to think about who posted this or that (unless it has to be a reliable current events source), why they posted it, and who else is looking at the same things I am. I take for granted the seemingly infinite amount of information on the internet. I forget that the World Wide Web has been woven so intricately by people as insignificant and anonymous as me. It's so true that we think of the internet as a powerful collective entity, and we are largely unaware of the complex individualism that has created and contributed to this world-wide system.
Next, I commented on Shea's post "Dialectics: Ignorance and Happiness." In this entry, Shea ponders what it means to choose the blue or red pill and remain ignorant of or learn about the power of the matrix. Shea concludes that a pure happiness can only be attained by choosing the red pill and learning the true nature of one's life.
Shea, I must say that I, like JLev, disagree with your assertion that real contentment can really only be found in the realm of truth. Happiness is an exclusively relative feeling. In fact, all emotions are merely comparative. I believe that if one is ignorant, he or she will experience happiness, sadness, anger, relief, etc. in proportionate doses to an enlightened being and think each emotion just as significant as that being would. This is because a truly ignorant person has not even the slightest inkling that they could experience and know of something "more." Their life is their life; they live and make do with what they have because its all they can do. Someone who is supposedly enlightened is doing the same thing, but with a different knowledge base for his or her respective life.
I would argue that Neo was not ignorant before he takes the red pill. He had seen glimpses of enlightenment through his computer screen; he was aware of Morpheus's character even in a world of ignorance. So, in Neo's case, we see his experiences in the red-pill world as much more satisfying than his experiences had been before meeting the crew of the Nebuchadnezzar because he was never 100% ignorant, but rather in a purgatory between ignorance and truth. For this, Neo is an anomaly! The majority of the people in the matrix will have perfectly real and satisfying emotions and experiences because they have absolutely no idea of the world beyond.
I certainly respect your conclusion, though, because if one were to experience ignorant happiness and then enlightened happiness, of course enlightened happiness would be much more profound and desirable. The point is that most people, if not everyone (depends on what you believe), will never feel both and be able to compare the two.
No comments:
Post a Comment